A standard theme within the YouTube creator neighborhood is to make movies ranking experiences with horrible on-line evaluations.
In fact, these creators have began searching for out cruises with harsh on-line rankings to see if they’re as dangerous as individuals say they’re.
Lately, Josh from the channel @TheBurntChip determined to take issues into his personal arms by taking his first-ever cruise on Costa Cruises’ Costa Toscana.
He begins off the video by sharing many on-line evaluations claiming the cruise line is crowded, disgusting, and that individuals don’t like the truth that one of many ships sank in 2012.
After boarding the ship along with his good friend Alfred, they famous the embarkation course of was fairly easy in comparison with what they anticipated after studying evaluations.
Seeing as their cabin was not fairly prepared but, the pair determined to go to the buffet to get one thing to eat.
The buffet itself was very busy, and other people have been pushing others round to attempt to get meals, an expertise that’s not uncommon on embarkation day.
Most passengers who’ve boarded are coming from a morning full of journey, with some even recent off flights, so after all, the logical factor could be to seize a complimentary meal.
Josh and Alfred lastly have been in a position to get meals after an extended wait, which ended up trying and tasting a bit underwhelming, although they remained hopeful that the extra upscale dinners they’d deliberate could be higher.
When the cabin was lastly prepared, the door was totally open they usually walked in to seek out solely a single mattress — sadly, Josh thought, primarily based on the images whereas reserving, that they might have two.
Costa Cruises does enable for king-size beds to be break up upon request, changing them with two twin-size beds, which might simply be achieved by talking with the assigned room steward.
Professional tip right here is at all times to learn what you’re reserving intently to ensure it’s the lodging you want or to determine what your choices are as soon as onboard.
Learn Additionally: What Are the Greatest Rooms on a Cruise Ship?
They have been additionally disenchanted that the on line casino was closed, however the cruise line particulars on its web site state that it opens solely when the ship is crusing.
The remainder of the content material options the creator’s experiences at events, dinners, and even a number of the ports they visited.
Sadly, the duo steadily harp on the truth that the ship has a 1-star assessment. Right here is the place some myth-busting is available in!
The 6,600-passenger Costa Toscana has a 2.5-star ranking on TripAdvisor, which isn’t almost as little as was claimed.
That is additionally primarily based on solely 470 evaluations, which might account for lower than 0.004% of passengers to ever go on this vessel. It’s protected to say this isn’t an incredible pattern measurement to go off of.
One other factor that Josh and Alfred steadily point out is that evaluations warn fellow passengers concerning the further bills in the case of web protection and drinks.
With a small quantity of analysis, they might have discovered that Costa Cruises presents drink and WiFi packages as most cruise traces do! Drink packages begin at as little as $25 a day, and Wi-Fi packages begin at as little as $7.50 a day.
Lastly, they have been anticipating overcrowding and lengthy traces, which isn’t uncommon for these bigger fashionable vessels. Fortunately, there’s a straightforward resolution — cruise on a smaller ship relatively than go on the ninth largest on the planet.
The video exhibits Josh and Alfred seemingly having an incredible cruising expertise, although they in the end left a 1.5-star assessment, which is nowhere to be discovered on TripAdvisor.
Hopefully, they’d a greater expertise than they admitted to on-line.
What’s the Take care of these Unhealthy Opinions?
You could have seen many of those sorts of movies popping up not too long ago, as extra creators are investigating cruises with low rankings.
Because the web goes although, a lot of this content material is clickbait to get viewers’ consideration. It’s working, as Josh’s new video, posted on March 20, 2025, already has 1 million views.
Nevertheless, it begs the query, how a lot is an excessive amount of in the case of this sort of content material?
Fellow YouTuber Tonio Guajardo made the same video again in February to see if Margaritaville at Sea’s Paradise was as dangerous as the web evaluations prompt — and was in the end pleasantly shocked by the cruising expertise.
Simply days earlier than that, Jack Pembrook posted a video about “the cruise from Hell” he took on Carnival Conquest, an expertise that additionally ended up being pleasing regardless of evaluations saying in any other case.
The excellent news is that there’s a cruise for everybody — and in case you are searching for particular facilities, packages, itineraries, and even all-inclusive experiences, there is no such thing as a lack of choices to select from.
Many evaluations on-line rave concerning the 186,364 gross ton Costa Toscana, proving the ship will not be everybody’s favourite nevertheless it nonetheless is pleasing for others.
On the finish of the day, don’t let evaluations make your cruise any much less enjoyable than it must be!
